Biological control for major horticultural pests
Some of the most damaging pests can thankfully be controlled using biological control. Here are the major pests and their controls;
1. Glasshouse whitefly (Trialeurodes vaporariorum):
CONTROL: A small chalcid wasp (Encarsia formosa), thought to have originated from South America, was discovered by chance in the UK in 1926. The adult parasitoids are 0.6mm long; the female has a dark coloured head and thorax with a pale yellow abdomen; the males are entirely dark. Females lay 50-100 eggs singly in the scale stage of the whitefly's life cycle. Parasitised scales turn black distinguishing them from whitish-green healthy scales. Those that have been parasitised die and adult parasites emerge through circular holes cut in the dorsal surface of the dead scales. Adult parasites feed on the sugary excretion known as honeydew that is produced by whiteflies.
Encarsia is supplied in the form of black scales on pieces of leaf or pasted onto cards. These cards or leaf portions should be fixed securely in a shaded position on infested plants. Adult parasites emerge within a few days and the first blackened scales should appear on the plants after about three weeks. This parasite is not effective against cabbage whitefly or other whitefly species.
2. Glasshouse red (two-spotted) spider mite (Tetranychus urticae)
CONTROL: This common pest breeds rapidly and is difficult to control effectively with pesticides, especially if resistant strains of the mite are present. A predatory mite (Phytoseiulus persimilis), originally from Chile, is now widely used in preference to pesticides.
- The predator is about the same size as glasshouse red spider mite (0.5 mm), but they can be distinguished if examined with a hand lens
- The predators have orange-red pear-shaped bodies, are more active than the pest, and can be seen running over the leaves, tapping the leaf surface with their front legs in search of prey
Glasshouse red spider mites are more lethargic and their body shape is rectangular and despite their common name, are usually yellowish-green with two dark patches. They may be entirely dark, or in the autumn they may become reddish-orange. The adult predators and their nymphs feed on the eggs, nymphal and adult stages of glasshouse red spider mite. The predators are dispatched as nymphs and adults these should be released in sheltered positions on infested plants. This predator does not control fruit tree red spider mite on apple and plum, but can be successful against glasshouse red spider mite on outdoor plants in the summer.
Other mites, Amblyseius spp., are also sold for control of red spider mite and some other glasshouse pests. These can be used earlier in the season when temperatures are as low as 10ºC.
A midge, Feliiella acarisuga, is also available this can be used early and late in the season and can find small hidden populations of its prey.
3. Glasshouse mealybugs (Pseudococcus and Planococcus spp.)
CONTROL: The waxy fibres that mealybugs secrete over themselves and their eggs, and their habit of infesting relatively inaccessible places on plants, reduces the effectiveness of insecticides. A ladybird predator (Cryptolaemus montrouzieri) native to Australia can overcome these problems. Both the adult ladybirds and larvae feed on mealybugs and their eggs. The adults are 3.5mm long and are of the typical ladybird shape with grey-black wing cases and a reddish-brown head and thorax. The ladybirds’ larvae resemble mealybugs, their shape is similar and, like mealybugs, they are covered by a white powdery wax. When fully grown, the ladybird larvae are more than twice as large as most mealybugs and have a more extensive wax coating.
This ladybird can lay up to 500 eggs if there is a plentiful supply of food. As with most biological controls, the mealybug ladybird needs warm conditions and does best when daytime temperatures are around 27ºC (80ºF). The predator should be released onto infested plants in the evening to reduce the risk of adult ladybirds flying up and escaping through ventilators. The beetles will generally stay on the plants once they have settled, although they will wander about if there is insufficient food.
Parasitic wasps, Leptomastix and Leptomastidea sp. are available in combination with Cryptolaemus for mealybug control from one supplier. Another supplier offers Hypoaspis mites for control of root mealybug (Rhizococcus species).
4. Scale insects
CONTROL: Some glasshouse species, such as soft scale (Coccus hesperidum) and hemispherical scale (Saisettia coffeae), can be kept in check by releasing parasitic wasps Metaphycus helvolus, Encyrtus spp. and Encarsia citrina. These lay eggs in scale nymphs, which become darkened and are killed. At 27ºC (80ºF) the life cycle from egg to adult wasp takes about 12 days but is slower at lower temperatures. These parasitoids need to be introduced in May to July for the best results.
CONTROL: There are a wide range of biological controls available for aphids (greenfly and blackfly). Many are native species that commonly occur in gardens. These parasites and predators often naturally reduce aphid problems by mid-summer in the garden but may need introducing into the glasshouse.
A small midge, Aphidoletes aphidimyza, whose larvae prey on aphids can give effective control in glasshouses from April to September. These tiny flies (< 3 mm) lay red eggs at night on the foliage, these may be laid singly or in clusters of up to 40. The females lay a total of about 100 eggs over a period of about fourteen days. The eggs hatch in about three days and the small orange-white larvae take 7 to fourteen days to complete their feeding before pupating in silk cocoons in the soil. Adults emerge about three weeks later. Pot plants should be stood on trays of damp sand, otherwise fully fed Aphidoletes larvae will drop down and fail to find anywhere to pupate.
The larvae are up to 3 mm long when fully grown and they feed by attaching themselves to an aphid's leg joint and sucking out the body contents. The larvae often feed underneath the aphids' bodies and may be difficult to see in dense aphid colonies. Sixty to eighty aphids can be killed by a single larva during its development. Control may be less satisfactory on plants with hairy leaves. Aphidoletes is supplied as larvae, which should be gently transferred to an aphid-infested plant with the aid of a soft paint brush, or as pupae which should be put in a cool damp place at the base of plants.
A species of green lacewing larva, Chrysoperla carnea, is commercially available. The adult has a slender pale green body, about 10mm long, with long thread-like antennae and transparent wings with many veins. The adults feed on pollen, nectar and honeydew but the larvae are voracious predators of aphids, other small insects and mites. The females lay white eggs that are raised off the leaf surface on silk threads 5-7mm long. This species of lacewing overwinters in sheltered places as adult insects.
Larvae and adults of the two-spot ladybird, Adalia bipunctata, can be purchased and should be placed on aphid infested plants from spring onwards. Adult ladybirds tend to disperse but the larvae stay where they have been put if aphids are present. Each ladybird will consume many hundreds of aphids during its lifetime.
Parasitic wasps, Aphidius, Praon or Aphelinus species are also available. These lay eggs in aphid nymphs, the larvae eat the internal contents of the aphid killing it, leaving a hollow swollen straw-brown or black skin known as an aphid mummy. Aphidius and Aphelnius species pupate within the hollowed out mummy, the adult wasp emerging from a circular hole it makes in the dorsal surface. The fully grown larvae of Praon species emerge from under the aphid spinning a silken cocoon that fastens the aphid mummy to the leaf. The parasites are supplied as adult wasps or parasitised aphids. These should be released or placed on plants in sheltered areas in the evening.
Aphid predators, such as the larvae of ladybirds, hoverflies and lacewings, can also be collected from garden plants and released into a glasshouse.
6. Caterpillars including codling moth
CONTROL: A pathogenic nematode, Steinernema carpocapsae, is available for the control of caterpillar pests, such as those on brassicas and for cutworms and other soil-dwelling caterpillars. When nematodes are watered onto the foliage, they need damp conditions to allow them time to infect the caterpillars with a bacterial disease, so apply during dull, cool weather.
7. Vine weevil (Otiorhynchus sulcatus)
CONTROL: The larvae of vine weevil feed on the roots of many plants, especially those being grown in pots or other containers. The grubs can be controlled by watering into the potting compost a suspension of the pathogenic nematode, Steinernema kraussei. For best results nematodes need to be used in a well-drained potting compost or light soil, which must be moist, in August to early September. Treatment at that time will control vine weevil grubs before they are large enough to cause serious damage.
Steinernema kraussei will remain active at soil temperatures down to 5ºC (41ºF), so control can also be achieved later in the autumn to spring period, although late treatment may fail to prevent some damage occurring. A different species of nematode, Heterorhabditis megidis, is available from Agralan Ltd, this requires soil temperatures of 12-20ºC (54-68ºF).
CONTROL: Several species of slugs cause damage in gardens, especially to seedlings, herbaceous plants and potato tubers. They can be controlled by a pathogenic nematode, Phasmarhabditis hermaphrodita. It can be used anytime when the soil is moist and above 5ºC (41ºF), but is best applied on several occasions between spring and autumn. Light sandy soils allow nematodes to move more freely through the soil; poor results may be achieved on heavy, poorly drained soils. Snails can be affected by the nematode but are less likely to come into contact with it as snails spend most of their lives on or above the soil surface.
9. Other biological controls – predators and parasites
Other controls are available for use in gardens and/or glasshouses:
- Chrysanthemum leaf miner: parasitic wasps, Dacnusa and Diglyphus spp.
- Sciarid fly/fungus gnat larvae: the mite, Hypoaspis miles and a rove beetle, Atheta coriaria, can be used as a predator
- Slug eggs, larvae of carrot root fly and cutworms: the rove beetle Atheta coriaria can be used in vegetable gardens to control these pests
- Thrips and other small insects in glasshouses: A predatory bug, Orius laevigatus
- Thrips, including western flower thrips, glasshouse red spider mite, fruit tree red spider mite, tarsonemid mite and citrus red spider mite: a predetory mite (Amblyseius species)
10. Other biological controls – nematodes
Other controls are available for use in gardens and/or glasshouses:
- Chafer grubs in lawns: Heterorhabditis megidis is available for control
- Larvae of cabbage root fly, carrot fly, onion fly, fungus gnats, cutworms, leatherjackets, caterpillars, gooseberry sawfly, thrips and codling moth: a mixture of nematode species, sold as Grow Your Own, is available
- Sciarid flies/fungus gnats, leatherjackets and ants in lawns: use different formulations of Steinernema feltiae